Powered by Jitbit AspNetForum free trial version.
     
From Screen to Theme
Where in the World

Trivia of the Day

Join Brent on:
Twitter Facebook
UStream

Disney Forums

Disney Forums


register | lost password | open id open id

Home » Live-Action Movies » Most Underappreciated Live Action Film?

Disney's Live-Action Movies
5/19/2010 8:01:37 AM

BrentDodge
BrentDodge
Administrator
Posts: 1195
What Disney film do you love that others just don't seem to care for or know about?

I've always loved Snowball Express and Candleshoe and most people look at me like I'm crazy since they've never even heard of these films. Which ones are yours?

--
Author of From Screen to Theme and host of the W.E.D.nesday Show!

"Anything can happen if you let it"
permalink • reply with quote
5/19/2010 3:22:39 PM

Escapay
Escapay
Posts: 78
I think Tuck Everlasting (2002) rarely gets its due from Disney fans. It came and went quietly in the theatres and didn't really get much notice on DVD. Plus, it came from a year that didn't really have any memorable live-action movies, most anything Disney was overshadowed by Lilo & Stitch that year.

For a Walt-Era film, I think his three "historicals" don't get enough recognition: The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men, The Sword and the Rose, and Rob Roy, the Highland Rogue. Whenever anyone thinks 1950s Disney, they automatically think of Cinderella, Alice in Wonderland, Peter Pan, Lady and the Tramp, Sleeping Beauty, "Disneyland" (the park and the show), 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, "Davy Crockett", etc.

--
permalink • reply with quote
5/19/2010 9:56:14 PM

Disneyfan80
Disneyfan80
Posts: 2749
I have 2 one old and one new, the old one is Treasure Island, I absolutely loved that movie.

The new movie some might think it isn't underappreciated but I do, and that movie is Miracle. Having met Herb Brooks and a few players from that team on quite a few occations, I really appreciate that miracle on ice more and more after hearing all the stories from them.

--
When you feel like giving up, remember why you held on so long in the first place.

Brent Dodge for President!

Loki: I have an army.
Tony Stark: We have a Hulk!!!!

Hi there! My name is Dug, my master made me this collar. He is a good and smart master and he made me this collar so that I may speak. Squirrel!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
permalink • reply with quote
5/20/2010 6:56:49 PM

dernamekim
dernamekim
Posts: 246
Clearly my choice (and Melissa's) would be Happiest Millionaire NO SHILLY SHALLYING

But on a serious note, I'm not sure what I would say. Maybe One Magic Christmas- I'm pretty sure that was Disney. Kristin and I used to watch that every Christmas because we loved Gideon the angel. I also loved the original Parent Trap but that is pretty well known.
permalink • reply with quote
5/22/2010 8:24:49 PM

EDITOR
EDITOR
Posts: 214
I agree with Brent: Snowball Express and Candleshoe. I would put Candleshoe ahead of Snowball Express for overall storyline and movie. Snowball Express would win for best individual scene between the two.

*** Fun fact: I have edited 14 chapters from Brent's upcoming book on Live Action Films. This is an excellent follow-up to his first book. If you have yet to attain a copy of book number one (or want a few extra copies to give as gifts for your friends), they can be purchased through this website. *** End of Fun Fact
permalink • reply with quote
8/10/2010 8:15:05 PM

Disneykid
Disneykid
Posts: 42
Return to Oz. I feel it captures Baum's Oz better than any other film adaptation I've seen (even if I admit the MGM musical is still the best movie overall). People who keep accusing it of being too somber are obviously only comparing it to the 1939 film, not Baum's books.

I wish Disney would treat this better on home video. There are deleted scenes and TV specials on YouTube that would make for a nice collection of bonus material. At least we get the very good Fairuza Balk interview, trailer, and TV spots.
edited by Disneykid on 8/10/2010

--
"Mustard?! Don't let's be silly!"
permalink • reply with quote
10/17/2010 5:49:14 PM

pap64
pap64
Posts: 179
The Three Lives of Thomasina: I remember watching this movie as a kid and enjoying it a lot. Being a big cat guy I understand what the little girl went through when she thought she was dead. Despite the "charming" theme and story it gets pretty dark and melancholy. Once again, it hits home to anyone that has ever loved a pet very hard. Plus, it's one of the few cat movies Disney has produced.



The Homeward Bound series: I am talking about the original Disney era film, the 1990s remake and its sequel. Like Thomasina this film sums up what it is to be the owner of a lost pet and tries to interpret what a pet feels. There are a lot of high tension moments, simply because the films ARE REAL. The pets are in real danger and it can get pretty uncomfortable watching (I always look for the "no animals were harm in the making of this film" statement just in case). Plus, they made the talking animal thing very tastefully, unlike nowadays with the new Buddies film. The second film, in particular, has a very strong message of pet care, and the scene where you see the puppy being tossed out in the rain is really, REALLY heartbreaking.



Gus: You guys remember how Disney fans were upset when Beverly Hills Chihuahua was announced, and how Disney had scrapped the bottom of the creative barrel? Well, every time someone makes that statement I point towards this film. Yeah it's stupid, nonsensical and irreverent, but gosh darn it it's the kind of silliness I love in a movie. I mean... IT'S A FOOTBALL PLAYING MULE! AND HE GETS DRUNK DURING A GAME! Just how ridiculously awesome that idea is??




Tron: Ok, Ok, technically I am cheating here cause Tron isn't THAT underrated. There were games, a Tron world in Kingdom Hearts II and there's a sequel coming up. But whenever someone does a best sci-fi films list or something like that, Tron gets ignored. This was a very unique concept that would be later used in films like The Matrix and many other movies involving digital worlds and videogames. Yeah it can get cheesy at times and the effects are not as captivating now, but it created an iconic look that people are still replicating.
edited by pap64 on 10/17/2010

--
permalink • reply with quote

Home » Live-Action Movies » Most Underappreciated Live Action Film?





Powered by AspNetForum 6.6.0.0 © 2006-2010 Jitbit Software